TFSA or RRSP: where should your next dollar go?
Enter your income today and the income expected in retirement. You see the option that leaves you the most, after tax, under these assumptions.
The option that leaves you the most, under these assumptions
The RRSP
- What the RRSP leaves you on top
- ≈ $830
- Your tax rate today
- ≈ 36%
- Your estimated rate in retirement
- ≈ 29%
The RRSP wins here because your tax rate drops in retirement. This result doesn’t account for your contribution room, your benefits or your other income.
Calculated by Dima’s engine, in your browser; nothing is linked to you or kept. site-calculatrices-qc-2026-v1
Three steps, no mystery.
- 01The RRSP: deducted, then taxed$5,000 invested in the RRSP. On withdrawal, tax is paid at your retirement rate: here, about 29%, with the Québec Pension Plan, OAS and RRIF withdrawals.
- 02The TFSA: taxed, then freeThe same $5,000 of income becomes about $3,190 after tax, invested in the TFSA. Nothing to pay on withdrawal.
- 03We compare what’s leftAfter tax, in 20 years, at the same return.
What the number doesn’t say.
- OAS and GISThe TFSA doesn’t countAn RRSP withdrawal counts as income and can reduce these benefits; a TFSA withdrawal doesn’t.
- Your roomTwo limitsYour RRSP limit is on your notice of assessment; your TFSA limit, in your online Canada Revenue Agency account.
- BothOften, the right answerMany households use both, depending on the year and their plans.
Notice
Illustrative result, calculated under the 2026 Québec and federal rules, for a Québec resident, from the data entered only. It is neither advice nor a plan. Updated: November 2, 2026.Illustrative result, under the 2026 Québec and federal rules, from the data entered only. It is neither advice nor a plan.